Judge Mary Kay Holthus, currently serving as the District Court Judge in Department 18, has built a distinguished legal career marked by an enduring commitment to the principles of justice. With over three decades of experience, Judge Holthus is recognized as a dedicated public servant who consistently upholds the values of law and order.
Her legal journey commenced in the role of Chief Deputy District Attorney, where she exhibited exceptional dedication throughout her 27-year tenure. Notably, she spent 16 years in the Special Victim’s Unit, passionately prosecuting cases involving sexual assault, child abuse, and domestic violence. Her efforts not only provided a voice to the victims but also contributed significantly to making the community safer.
Transitioning to the bench two years ago, Judge Holthus faced initial scrutiny from civil litigants due to her relatively limited experience in civil litigation. However, her diligence and work ethic quickly dispelled any concerns. Leveraging her extensive experience as a trial lawyer, including approximately 150 jury trials during her time in the DA’s office, she embraced the challenge of presiding over both civil and criminal cases.
Acknowledging the importance of addressing the underlying concerns of offenders, Judge Holthus actively pursued a comprehensive understanding of the legal landscape. She attended the National Judicial College of General Jurisdiction and sought guidance from experienced colleagues to bridge the gap in her civil litigation experience. Despite early critiques, she has demonstrated her commitment to fairness and impartiality on the bench.
One prevalent concern related to her prosecutorial background revolves around the perception of bias in criminal cases. However, Judge Holthus firmly asserts that her ethics remain unchanged. With 16 years dedicated to the Special Victim’s Unit, she brings a unique perspective to balancing justice for victims and fairness to the accused. Her experience in distinguishing between career criminals and those who may benefit from diversionary programs underscores her commitment to longer-term solutions for both individuals and the community.
As a dedicated public servant, Judge Mary Kay Holthus continues to navigate her split docket with grace, presiding over both criminal and civil calendars. Her multifaceted approach to the law, coupled with her unwavering dedication to justice, ensures that she remains a steadfast advocate for the safety and well-being of the community she serves.